Monday 11 August 2008

Want Help Deconstructing Clues?

crossword-help
If you have the clue text and its solution, but can't figure out how the clue leads to the solution - you can post both in the comments section. I'll try to help with analyzing the clue.

Note: Please post cryptic crossword clues only, and mention the source/setter of the clue.

Stay connected with Crossword Unclued. Get new articles delivered directly into your inbox or subscribe to our RSS Feed.  Do check out our Facebook page, click on the Like button to get instant information about blog updates and other interesting crossword trivia. See you there!

142 comments:

  1. Hi Suchi,

    Your blog is very well written and neatly organized. I liked that you have kept your writing simple and you have chosen a white theme, which makes me feel like that there's a big board called "Demystified Here!"

    My question is pretty simple THC 9366 -


    17a Firearm, good French one (3)


    I know the answer, but ..why?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Glad that you like the blog.

    The clue you asked about is a charade.

    Firearm = definition
    good = G (the abbreviation for good)
    French one = UN (the number 1 in French)

    So the answer is GUN.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Shuchi,

    Help again - THC 9368

    British honor would exclude one beginning to tope (7)

    How does the net come in?

    ReplyDelete
  4. It's like this:

    British honor = definition [should've been spelt 'honour', since we're talking British not American :) ]

    would = connector

    exclude = BAR
    one = ONE
    beginning to tope = the letter T

    So it is a charade, giving BAR ONE T.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi i am a newbie with hindu crossword, so trying to figure out how to solve based on solutions!
    Could you help me solve this
    Tempts with ten cooked desserts (7)

    answer: entices. how does ices make cooked desserts ?

    ReplyDelete
  6. @Mithr: 'cooked' is an anagram indicator for 'ten' here, not an adjective for 'desserts'. Read it this way:
    ten (cooked) + desserts = anagram of TEN + ICES = ENTICES

    Words like cooked, scrambled, baked, etc. tend to be anagram indicators in cryptic clues. For further reading: How To Spot Anagrams.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hello Shuci!

    Wonderful work in here. :-)


    Here's my doubt and I sure shall pepper you with many more.

    THC 9511:

    Profile of Conservative leader visiting constituencies? (7)

    Thanks in advance.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hi Anish, The answer should be CONTOUR, but I know that it doesn't fit into the grid!

    conservative=C, visting constituencies=ON TOUR, and profile is the definition.

    Seems to be an error here, as this doesn't match the crossings. Let's wait for tomorrow's solutions to see what the compiler expected. My guess is, the answer will turn out to be COUNTOR.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hi, can u explain the annotation of the following clues
    1) Unhappy dictator offering no obstruction(3)--> SAD
    - unhappy--> defn.. but why "dictator..."
    2)Cover for head with hard manner(4)--> HAIR
    - Cover for head is HAIR
    hard manner??

    3) Seen as animal is about to pull back(8)--> REGARDED..
    4) Interferes with first time service-person (6)-->PRIEST

    Source: ET Bangalore July 26,2009

    ReplyDelete
  10. Hi Nischal,

    1) SAD = SADDAM (dictator) - DAM (obstruction)

    2) HAIR = charade of H (standard abbrev. for 'hard') AIR (manner, as in 'he has a regal air')

    3) REGARDED = DEER (animal) around DRAG (pull), all reversed (back is the reversal indicator)

    4) PRIEST = charade of PRIES (interferes) T (first letter of 'time')

    ReplyDelete
  11. From Guardian:
    Someone on the go drinking mineral also (8)MOREOVER

    Couldn't understand this one.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Welcome here, Aim!

    Someone on the go drinking mineral also (8)MOREOVER
    also: definition
    someone on the go = MOVER
    drinking = c/c indicator
    mineral = ORE

    ReplyDelete
  13. Aha! now makes sense, thanks!
    I cound't get it despite knowing the answer and definition.

    ReplyDelete
  14. How about this clue, which I wrote?
    It takes freshman to stop the prisoner (6)

    Am not posting it here for you to solve it, but to know if it makes sense.

    ReplyDelete
  15. It takes freshman to stop the prisoner (6)
    I think the surface is fair enough. It is grammatically sound, and though one might wonder "why freshman?" - something like IG or head of police is more plausible - but it's acceptable.

    The issue is with the cryptic grammar. "stop the", isn't the same as "stop of the" or "the's stop". I like 'freshman' = NMA, but even that's considered not OK by strict standards.

    An interesting attempt, though. See if you can re-write the E part!

    ReplyDelete
  16. Thanks Shuchi. I did want to know your opinion about the freshman and the 'E' part.

    ReplyDelete
  17. One more, written by me:

    Men assemble in unknown country (7)

    ReplyDelete
  18. The anagrind needs to be either an instruction to the solver [Assemble XYZ], or a property of the fodder [XYZ assembled]. The 2nd way would fit in well with your clue.

    I also think unknown = DARK is slightly imprecise. How about mysterious/dismal/sinister instead of unknown?

    ReplyDelete
  19. Thanks Shuchi.
    Yes, you are right on both counts.
    Especially about the anagrind I never thought it that way.

    ReplyDelete
  20. I like Sankalak. In today's CW I particularly liked "Carbon become aluminium? After negative start? Happening in the night? (9)", for the way it framed it.

    But was wondering is there grammatical mistake? 'Carbon become' or 'Carbon becomes?'

    ReplyDelete
  21. 'become' isn't grammatically correct for the surface, but if it's 'becomes' it'll spoil the answer (becomes = TURNS not TURN).

    Is this a Sankalak clue?

    ReplyDelete
  22. Yes it was Sankalak.
    Of course Carbon becomes aluminium will spoil the clue. Doesn't Carbon become aluminium still spoil it?

    ReplyDelete
  23. Well, 'become' spoils the surface, 'becomes' spoils the wordplay. He chose the lesser evil of the two.

    ReplyDelete
  24. :)
    You always give convincing reply :)

    ReplyDelete
  25. Hi,
    Totally didn't get this one! - THC 9283
    She has managed a first class title (7) - LETITIA

    ReplyDelete
  26. Hi fiddlesticks,
    It's first class = A1, jumbled with TITLE. "has managed" is the anagrind.

    Hat-tip to Vinod (via chat) for spotting it straightaway.

    ReplyDelete
  27. "Carbon become aluminium? After negative start? Happening in the night? (9)"

    I ahppen to see this section and this discussion only today. Sorry for a late reaction.

    I would think that the clue written is OK. I take 'become' as a past participle with 'has' understood.

    Don't we come across the expression "Dream come true", where we mean that a deram that we had has since come true.

    Of course, we had an editor in Indian Express, whom I looked upon as a scholar and who wrote excellent English with a literary flavour, arguing that the expression "Dream come true" was wrong. But, for me usage is idiomatic.

    ReplyDelete
  28. New here.Great job on this blog. Looking forward to spending a lot of time here
    I need help in deconstructing one from the Guardian..

    Kelly becomes well-informed by following one who wrote nonsense (7)

    Could you please help?

    ReplyDelete
  29. Hi sriks7,

    Thanks and I look forward to having you here.

    Kelly becomes well-informed by following one who wrote nonsense (7) LEAR NED

    This is one of those rare cases where the definition sits in the middle. NED (Kelly) follows LEAR (one who wrote nonsense), to become LEARNED (well-informed).

    Guardian crosswords are discussed on the daily solving blog 15sqd. It's a great site, bookmark it!

    ReplyDelete
  30. Hi Shuchi :)

    First of all, thanks a lot for running this site. I'm still very much an amateur at cryptic crosswords but this site has been really helpful to me. Thanks!

    I've got one from the Times that I'm having difficulty understanding, if you wouldn't mind:

    Slight reduction in price coming on stream for barbecue (9)

    So as not to spoil it for anyone else, the answer is here (Link is to Dictionary.com via bit.ly)

    Thanks in advance!

    Owen

    ReplyDelete
  31. Hi Owen, welcome here.

    Slight reduction in price coming on stream for barbecue (9)

    price = CHARGE,
    Slight reduction in price => delete a little bit of CHARGE. Usually, in the Times, this implies a single-letter truncation at the end of the word. (With some of the Guardian setters, the truncation could be of 2 letters or even more.)
    'coming on' is a link word between the wordplay components.
    stream = RILL

    'for' links the wordplay to the definition, 'barbecue'.

    ReplyDelete
  32. Thank you, that's brilliant! I didn't actually know the word "rill", so you learn something new every day :)

    Thanks again,
    Owen

    ReplyDelete
  33. Hi,
    Being new, I came across this post dtd Aug 9 2009 from Aim-a clue,'it takes freshman to stop the prisoner'. What did u mean by the'NMA' and 'E' parts of the clue and what is the solution? You see, I've been solving crosswords with no idea of the technicalities involved and am astounded by the depth and precision of your site. Kudos to you! And thanks. Sumitra

    ReplyDelete
  34. Hi Sumitra, the expected solution for 'It takes freshman to stop the prisoner (6)' is INMATE.

    freshman = fresh-MAN i.e anagram of MAN
    It takes freshman => IT contains (MAN)*
    'stop the' is supposed to indicate E, the last letter of 'the'.

    The main problem is that 'stop the' isn't the same as 'stop of the'. It isn't considered OK to join the anagrind and fodder as in 'freshman' (I don't mind it much, personally).

    See clue#2 on this post about unXimenean clues, for a clue with a similar issue.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Hi Shuchi. I try to make sense of all the clues/answers when I complete a crossword. I have a few I'm stuck on that you may be able to explain for me:

    [PRETTIER]
    Publicity row about film being made more attractive
    >'more attractive' = 'prettier' but what about the rest?

    [LAOS]
    Where you may have a kip for money

    [CUTE]
    Clever stroke to point

    [YORKSHIRE]
    Grit found in the pudding?
    >I know of 'yorkshire pudding' but where does 'grit' come into this?

    [TALISMAN]
    Scottish charm
    >talisman = charm, but where does 'scottish' come in?

    [YARN]
    Long pointless story
    >this looks like a straight clue to me, am I missing the 'cryptic' behind it?

    [SIDE]
    Team’s boastful manner
    >team = side, but where does 'boastful manner' come in?

    [DOWNING STREET]
    Drunk deserting town road where policeman stands guard

    [FACTIONS]
    Loud goings-on associated with
    society parties

    [PROMOTERS]
    They stage sporting events in favour of cars we hear

    [ONE FOR THE ROAD]
    Ill-advised drink taken by somebody going from saloon to saloon?

    ...Ok, maybe there were a bit more than a few :) but I hope you can help anyway

    ReplyDelete
  36. Hi AlmostThere,
    Answering the first few...have to step out for dinner, will get back later on the others. Which crossword are these from? Maybe there's a solution blog/forum for it out there somewhere.

    [PRETTIER]
    Publicity row about film being made more attractive
    >'more attractive' = 'prettier' but what about the rest?
    PR (publicity) + TIER (row) around ET (film)

    [LAOS]
    Where you may have a kip for money
    This is a cryptic definition. 'Kip' is the currency of Laos.

    [CUTE]
    Clever stroke to point
    CUT (stroke) E (point). defn: clever


    [YORKSHIRE]
    Grit found in the pudding?
    >I know of 'yorkshire pudding' but where does 'grit' come into this?
    Perhaps 'grit found in [this place]' has to do with the sedimentary rock formations in Yorkshire.

    [TALISMAN]
    Scottish charm
    >talisman = charm, but where does 'scottish' come in?
    The Talisman is a novel by Sir Walter Scott.

    [YARN]
    Long pointless story
    >this looks like a straight clue to me, am I missing the 'cryptic' behind it?
    Long = YEARN, pointless => remove the 'E', defn: story. It's interesting that the whole clue reads like the definition too.

    [SIDE]
    Team’s boastful manner
    >team = side, but where does 'boastful manner' come in?
    'pretentious air;arrogance' is a secondary meaning of SIDE.

    ReplyDelete
  37. The remaining ones...

    [DOWNING STREET]
    Drunk deserting town road where policeman stands guard
    Anagram of (DESERTING TOWN), with 'drunk' as anagrind. defn: where policeman stands guard


    [FACTIONS]
    Loud goings-on associated with society parties
    F (loud) ACTIONS (goings-on)

    [PROMOTERS]
    They stage sporting events in favour of cars we hear
    defn: They stage sporting events; we hear => homophone; PRO (in favour of) MOTORS (cars)

    [ONE FOR THE ROAD]
    Ill-advised drink taken by somebody going from saloon to saloon?
    'Ill-advised drink taken by somebody going from saloon' refers to the meaning of the idiom, with 'saloon' = bar. The second 'saloon' can mean a sedan car, which is also 'one for the road'.

    ReplyDelete
  38. Thanks Shuchi, you're so clever! All the clues make sense now :-)!

    The clues are all from The Daily Telegraph Cryptic Crossword Book, Volume 62.

    ReplyDelete
  39. Can you please help with this one from the telegraph yesterday (24/5/10)?

    Issue raised by a gold prospector.

    The answer was clementine but I just cant work out why!!!

    ReplyDelete
  40. Have you heard this song? It opens with:

    In a cavern, in a canyon,
    Excavating for a mine
    Dwelt a miner forty niner,
    And his daughter Clementine


    That's what the clue is alluding to. Issue => the daughter of the miner.

    By the Telegraph, do you mean The Daily Telegraph of UK? If so, you must follow Big Dave's blog.

    ReplyDelete
  41. Thanks so much Shuchi I can now get some sleep!

    ReplyDelete
  42. Can anyone help me to please understand a couple of clues in an old Telegraph puzzle book (2005 -DT Big Book of Cryptic Puzzles)?

    9d: He was brave so was she (A =Hero -I know a hero is brave but why the so was she part?)

    18a: Witnesses a key agreement (A =eyes, so to witness is to eye but I dont get the key agreement?)

    24A: After the salmon she gets food poisoning (A =Ella: I just dont get that at all!

    ReplyDelete
  43. I've worked out the Ella clue- Salmonella -I woke up and it just occurred to me- amazing!

    ReplyDelete
  44. 9d: He was brave so was she (A =Hero -I know a hero is brave but why the so was she part?)

    Probably from the Greek myth of Hero and Leander? Not very convincing...let me think a bit more.

    18a: Witnesses a key agreement (A =eyes, so to witness is to eye but I dont get the key agreement?)

    E = a key (the musical key)
    YES = agreement

    ReplyDelete
  45. Yes, the reference does seem to be to Hero and Leander, although HERO didn't exactly give herself heroic status by chucking herself off t'balcony into t'sea. Taking easy way out, if you ask me.

    I think what's happened is that the various figures in Greek legend tend to be listed under hero/heroine.

    ReplyDelete
  46. Thanks anax. I had the same thoughts about the clue. Not a very good clue, in that case.

    ReplyDelete
  47. Many thanks again Shuchi and also to anax- you've saved me a lot of sleepless nights again!

    ReplyDelete
  48. Hi Shuchi,

    Do help me in understanding how one arrives at the solution

    Clue: country professor on staff gets first-class write-up (9)

    Answer: Macedonia.

    Thanks and regards

    R

    ReplyDelete
  49. Hi R

    Country professor on staff gets first-class write-up (9)
    professor = DON
    staff = MACE
    professor ON staff => DON after MACE

    first-class = A1
    write-up => reversal

    Put together, it is MACE DON (A1)<

    ReplyDelete
  50. Thanks Shuchi. That was one of Rufus' clue.

    regards
    R

    ReplyDelete
  51. hi shuchi
    i am a beginner and i find the thc a bit tough. can you suggest a good book or any other source of cryptic CW's for beginners.

    this blog helped me a lot to understand the intricacies of cryptics
    thank you for the time and effort invested in this blog...

    ReplyDelete
  52. Hi febin

    Do you follow the blog The Hindu Crossword Corner? Explanations of daily THC solutions are published there, and if there's something you don't understand you can ask in their comments.

    I can recommend the book How To Master The Times Crossword by Tim Moorey, it works very well as a guide to cryptic crosswords. More on the book here.

    All the best.

    ReplyDelete
  53. Hi shuchi,

    I am a beginner at CW and am making one.Are these clues acceptable?

    1)Such a liquid is pure,solid is not.(7)
    2)Reduced decaying is still decaying ?(5)
    3)From top to bottom, identify expression of approval(4)

    ReplyDelete
  54. Hi Suchi,

    I'm back. I need help with this clue from today's THC

    Shakespearean character: worker followed by most of the head (7) - {ANT}{ONIOn}

    How is head Onion?

    ReplyDelete
  55. Hi Anonymous, 'onion' is slang for 'head'...to be off one's onion is to be off one's head.

    ReplyDelete
  56. Strange how Edgar appeared to his
    friends (9)
    Revealed what one’s former partner
    stood for (7)
    I know the answers but apparently i don't see the inkling as to why the answers are what they are.. I am new to solving cryptic crosswords and i can tell you it's getting the better of me :(

    ReplyDelete
  57. Hi KSK

    Welcome!

    Revealed what one’s former partner stood for (7) EXPOSED
    EX (former partner) POSED (stood)

    The clue seems a bit loose - "what one's" and "for" do not fit into the wordplay.

    Not sure of the other one. It would be nice if you post the answer and the source with the clue, as I've mentioned in the preamble.

    Since you're new to cryptics, I'd recommend solving good quality, easy crosswords to start with. There are blogs for all the popular crosswords that explain each clue. Follow them, you'll soon learn the ropes. All the best!

    ReplyDelete
  58. Hi,
    Clue is from Globe and mail Canada Day 2011 cryptic crossword:

    119d
    Retailer's favorite putter (4)

    Thanks
    (so far I have is_e )

    ReplyDelete
  59. Hi, This is a clue from Deccan Herald B'lore Thu 7 Jul,

    Support for coppers(4)

    Ans: Pro-p

    Could u plz explain the annotation

    ReplyDelete
  60. @Anonymous: Can't think of any word that fits. Did you find out the answer?

    @Nischal:
    Support for coppers(4) PROP
    Definition: support
    for = PRO (i.e. in favour of)
    coppers = P. Coppers is slang for coins like the British penny, abbreviated as P.

    ReplyDelete
  61. FT Crossword 13,831 by Cincinnus.
    17 Down Clue "Trees with resident birds" - Answer "Swallows".

    The birds connection is obvious,but where is the link to the rest of the clue?

    Ken F

    ReplyDelete
  62. Welcome here Ken F.

    Trees = SALLOWS,
    with = W (a standard abbreviation);
    'resident' indicates that W is contained in SALLOWS.

    For clues from FT, Guardian and more, you must check out the excellent Fifteensquared.

    ReplyDelete
  63. uHi Suchi,
    ET 5126 (Kolkatta edition)

    Charles and sibling briefly provide a framework (7)
    Solution is Chassis
    Sis - Sis(ter) sibling partly
    then is it chas for charles how?

    ReplyDelete
  64. Hi Lakshmi,

    Chas is a standard short form of the name Charles, like Don for Donald or Ted for Edward.

    ReplyDelete
  65. Hi Suchi,
    Just a try.It crossed my mind.

    "An Army officer is the essence."

    Is this a correct clue?

    ReplyDelete
  66. Depends on the answer, Lakshmi.

    ReplyDelete
  67. I got this clue while reading about similar sounding words.
    here i thought of "colonel" as the answer which sounds like "kernel" = essence.

    ReplyDelete
  68. 'colonel' sounds like 'kernel', that is good. What the clue needs is a homophone indicator.

    ReplyDelete
  69. ET 5145 Kolkatta
    Short time after the year when first getting share of government (14)
    Ans: Administration
    short time = min
    year = ad
    share =ration
    ist how?

    ReplyDelete
  70. Hi suchi,
    Telegraph 10305
    Commotion involving amateur sailors ordered about in hurricane(7)
    Ans: TORNADO

    ADO - commotion
    TORN - How is this part arrived at?

    ReplyDelete
  71. Hi Lakshmi,

    Commotion involving amateur sailors ordered about in hurricane(7)

    It is actually TO(RN A)DO

    commotion = TO-DO
    involving => c/c indicator
    amateur = A
    sailors = RN (Royal Navy)
    ordered about => turn around the positions of A RN.

    ReplyDelete
  72. Hi Suchi,
    Thanks for the previous clue explanation. One more

    ET 5191
    Removal of these from the ear will give her chances (4). Ans: ODDS
    I saw Big Dave's blog but could'nt understand the explanation.

    ReplyDelete
  73. Sorry that clue was from Telegraph 10329

    ReplyDelete
  74. That's a very interesting clue Lakshmi.

    Removal of these from the ear will give her chances (4)

    defn: chances
    wordplay: Removal of odds i.e. odd letters from THEEAR will give HER.

    ReplyDelete
  75. new to this, I'm picking up old globe and mail cryptics that my mom saved and in one, "Main line terminals" is the clue. I've got _ e_p_ _ _ _ and i think it ends with "ends", for terminals. but I can't get the first part. any help?

    ReplyDelete
  76. Looks like SEAPORTS [cd];
    main = sea and line = line of transportation, as in shipping line.

    ReplyDelete
  77. Hi,
    I'm sure this is a cryptic crossword, but cant seem to work it out:

    Let ingenious gold head twist

    Any ideas where to start?

    ReplyDelete
  78. Looks like an anagram. What is the letter count?

    ReplyDelete
  79. Hi Shuchi,

    That part was left off and is killing me. I figured that the answer is an anagram becuase of "twist", but havent been able to work out much. Taken it many directions, but all dead ends for me. I have to admit that I'm fairly new to cryptics and not that great.

    Could "Let ingenious" = let in genius?

    ReplyDelete
  80. "Let ingenious gold head twist":

    I suspect that this is just an acrostic, giving LIGHT, rather than (all of a) crytpic crossword clue.

    ReplyDelete
  81. Nicely done Qix. I don't think I've seen a more debatable collection of words called a 'clue' in my life!

    ReplyDelete
  82. Hey there Qix,

    I picked up on LIGHT early on. The seemingly unreleated words along with "let...twist" made me think there might have been more to it.

    ReplyDelete
  83. Hi Shuchi
    This is from NIE Dtd: 31.08.2012.

    2dn: Offal and joint put together in one vessel (9)
    The ans is Lightship.

    Another clue of the same paper and Date.

    Look for a cause of inflation (3)

    Ans: Air

    Can you please help how the answres have been arrived at.
    Thank you.
    Laxman

    ReplyDelete
  84. Hi Laxman,

    Offal and joint put together in one vessel (9) LIGHTSHIP

    Definition: one vessel
    Wordplay: LIGHTS (offal, as in meat) HIP (joint)

    Look for a cause of inflation (3) AIR
    This is a dd.
    Definition 1: look (He has the look/air of self-assurance.)
    Definition 2: a cause of inflation i.e. swelling up

    ReplyDelete
  85. Thanks, Shuchi.
    In the first clue i couldn't connect lights with meat.
    The second clue was completely out of my reach. Thouh after your explanation it seems so easy.
    Thanks again
    Laxman

    ReplyDelete
  86. I'm doing old Globe and Mail cryptics, this one from november 8, 2010. The clue is "Divine meaning" (5 letters, I have an "a" in the second position) and I'm stuck. I tried words for divine like blessed, learn, but they won't work. I'm not sure what meaning does for tricky clues either. Any help? Thanks, you've helped me before.

    ReplyDelete
  87. Divine meaning (5) could be a cd for CATCH. Does it fit with the crossings?

    ReplyDelete
  88. I'll look up the term cd in your hints. Thanks. Yes, there is only one crossing so it works for that. And "catch" adds a "t" to it's 4th position. That clue, which I'm also stuck on, is "small company is safe from such failures". It is 8 letters with an "i" in the second position, a "t" in the 4th, an "o in the 6th and an "e" in the 8th. So I have _i_t_o_e

    ReplyDelete
  89. oops! me again about the "small company..." clue. the crossing of catch left a "c" in the 4th position, not a "t". So I have _i_c_o_e. I want to say it is "disclose" but only have "di" for two as in "two's company" (three's a crowd). But that seems like reaching.

    ReplyDelete
  90. Suchi, did you stop posting? I'm the old Globe and Mail cryptic do-er. I hope it wasn't something I said...

    ReplyDelete
  91. Hey Old G&M doer, I'm sorry for the very late reply! Thanks for reminding me :)

    The answer to "Small company is safe from such failures (8)" has to be FIASCOES (co + is + safe)*.

    Which means that your 4th and 8th letters need a change.

    "Divine meaning (5)" SENSE dd - does that fit?

    ReplyDelete
  92. THE HINDU No 2715, Sunday 02 Dec 12

    One retaliating against English sovereign after first of attacks (7) - AVENGER ENG(lish) + ER (sovereign)+ (A)ttacks where does the V come from?

    ReplyDelete
  93. Hi Lakshmi, V = versus (against).

    ReplyDelete
  94. Thanks Suchi I took " One retaliating against" as definition and got confused.

    ReplyDelete
  95. Hi Shuchi,(This time I wrote your name correctly)
    ET 5110 (Chennai)
    Big result of taking part in a long row there and back.(6)

    I have G_O_T_ so the answer is GROWTH (lonG ROW THere). But what is "and back" doing here?

    ReplyDelete
  96. Hi Lakshmi,

    "and back" looks like padding to make the hidden word less obvious - if so, not the most elegant way of going about it.

    ReplyDelete
  97. Hi Shuchi,
    I have'nt come across a "T" type clue of this type. I wanted to know whether it is "T" type or not or misunderstood the clue.

    ReplyDelete
  98. Hi Lakshmi, Yes it is a 'T' type of clue, but not a very good one IMO since it has extra words in the fodder.

    You can see more examples of such clues here:
    A thought about hidden word clues.

    ReplyDelete
  99. Hi Shuchi,
    Can you Please give annos for these clues from pressandjournal xwrd/UK dated Feb 9 2013
    Pretend to be ill we hear to get a drink. Ans: CHAMPAGNE
    Start talking back in a foreign language. Ans : LATIN

    ReplyDelete
  100. Pretend to be ill we hear to get a drink. Ans: CHAMPAGNE
    homophone of 'sham pain' (pretend to be ill)

    Start talking back in a foreign language. Ans : LATIN
    TAL[k] reversed, IN. 'TAL = Start TALKING' is a bit of a stretch, but this seems to be the most likely explanation.

    ReplyDelete
  101. Hi Shuchi
    Congratulations for the Indian Crossword League.
    Can you help me with the annos of answers to the clues (all from New Indian Express of Dt:2.12.2013).
    1. Dot Carried from Premises? (5,5)
    Ans: Point Taken
    2.Doesn't Encourage Delays (4,3)
    Ans: Puts Off
    3.Dead spirit to rap (4)
    Ans: DRUM

    ReplyDelete
  102. Thanks Laxman.

    1. Dot Carried from Premises? (5,5)
    Ans: Point Taken
    [cd] In the cryptic reading, "premises" would be suppositions.

    2.Doesn't Encourage Delays (4,3)
    Ans: Puts Off
    [dd] "doesn't encourage" and "delays" e.g. She was hungry but the bad food put her off eating. She had to put off her travel plans as her leave request was not approved.

    3.Dead spirit to rap (4)
    Ans: DRUM
    D (dead) + RUM (spirit - liquor); definition: rum

    ReplyDelete
  103. Thank You Shuchi.
    Can you help out with the annos of the following clues please.
    1. Spectacle in which a bull
    appears? (5) SIGHT
    2. Girl's given approval as flying
    controller (8) JOYSTICK. Is
    Girl = JOY? I think approval =
    Tick. Def is Flying controller.
    3. Amphibian decapitated - not
    right(3) EFT. Is Amphibian= L?
    4. A way of approach that isn't
    welcomed? (6) INROAD
    5. Enduring advice on how to get
    old? (8) LIVELONG
    6. An outstanding part of the
    country (8) HEADLAND
    What does a question mark indicate at the end of a clue?
    Sorry If I am bothering you.
    Regards
    Laxman

    ReplyDelete
  104. Forgot to mention the source of all the above clues. It is The New Indian Express of 3rd December 2013.

    ReplyDelete
  105. Hi Laxman, Just noticed a reply to your question was pending. Hope this is still useful.

    1. Spectacle in which a bull appears? (5) SIGHT
    Cryptic reference to bulls-eye; defn: spectacle.

    2. Girl's given approval as flying controller (8) JOYSTICK
    JOY'S (girl's) TICK (approval); defn: flying controller.

    3. Amphibian decapitated - not right(3) EFT
    LEFT (not right) decapitated i.e. with head removed

    4. A way of approach that isn't welcomed? (6) INROAD
    cd; an inroad is a hostile incursion

    5. Enduring advice on how to get old? (8) LIVELONG
    d&cd; Live long = advice on how to get old; defn: enduring

    6. An outstanding part of the country (8) HEADLAND
    cd - play on the word 'outstanding'

    What does a question mark indicate at the end of a clue?

    A question mark usually indicates a cd, but not always.

    ReplyDelete
  106. Thanks Suchi. I haven't made much headway in learning the crosswords, so it is still useful to me.

    ReplyDelete
  107. Please help, I've got the answer but not the reasoning behind it.

    4d) The bull's-eye's to invent something valuable (4,4)

    Answer ?o?d ?o?n Gold Coin

    Please can you work your magic on this

    ReplyDelete
  108. @Olivia Woods: double defn - "something valuable", and "bull's eye" as in archery.

    ReplyDelete
  109. hi nice blog can you help me with this cryptic crossword

    'Seems like, the jumbled mail joined the start of the delivery man' (5)

    it might refer to a name cause its from a video game i play

    ReplyDelete
  110. @jag: Looks like that. An anagram of MAIL + D (1st letter of 'delivery').

    ReplyDelete
  111. I need some help. The cryptic is: Irish enduring a slaughter. My solution is "erase" but I can't be confident of the connections.
    thanks.

    ReplyDelete
  112. @Glenn: Irish enduring a slaughter (5) ERASE
    ERSE (Irish i.e. the Irish Gaelic language) around A; definition: slaughter

    ReplyDelete
  113. From UK free paper Metro this morning. They don't mention the setter but yesterday's was a wholesale copy of one from the Scotsman in 2005.

    He supplies tea - with or without sugar (6)

    Answer is GROCER.

    Am I missing something or is it just that grocers sell both tea and sugar?

    Thank you for any enlightenment.

    ReplyDelete
  114. @Paul Marcroft: Can't see more than you do in that clue. Does this puzzle have other straight-ish definitions? If so, we needn't think further.

    ReplyDelete
  115. Thanks Shuchi. Glad to know I'm not missing something. It's not the best crossword in the world but it's usually slightly more diverting than the Evening Standard. Having done another week's worth since my previous post, I think we don't need to consider it any further.

    Paul.

    ReplyDelete
  116. A military music man - and very superior with it. Answer Sousa. But I do not get second half of clue.

    ReplyDelete
  117. @Mike Mifa:

    The second half is a charade of SO (very) U (superior, in the sense of posh) SA (it).

    (⇑ Follow the links for more details on how those substitutions work.)

    ReplyDelete
  118. Many thanks for that help, Shuchi.

    ReplyDelete
  119. Wake in rural retreat. Answer is backwater but I do not understand why. Daily telegraph 2 June 2004. From Mike Mifa again.

    ReplyDelete
  120. @Mike Mifa:

    "Wake in rural retreat" looks like a double definition.

    One (less-used) meaning of wake is "the track of waves left by a ship or other object moving through the water".

    Backwater is also a rural retreat.

    ReplyDelete
  121. Had not thought of that. Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  122. She takes things in her stride. Answer is Walker but seems hardly cryptic and why she unless it relates to Coronation Street character?

    ReplyDelete
  123. Picture, say, a great way to get a rise. Answer is image. Get a rise? Daily Telegraph one day in 2004. Mike Mifa.

    ReplyDelete
  124. @Mike Mifa:

    She takes things in her stride
    is probably meant to be a cryptic definition. I'm reading it as "a person that walks", with "she" for misdirection - just the opposite of the surgeon riddle.

    Picture, say, a great way to get a rise
    "to get a rise" here indicates a reversal in a DOWN clue, of EG (say = for example) A M1 (great way).

    ReplyDelete
  125. I've had one today, I can't understand

    'Amateurs compete for it' . the answer is LOVE but i can't understand why

    ReplyDelete
  126. Amateurs compete for it (4) LOVE looks like a cryptic definition. An 'amateur' is an athlete who competes without payment i.e. "for love".

    ReplyDelete
  127. Hi, request your in understanding:
    1. Lists some rogues(5) [HEELS]
    2. Very light, for example(5) [FLARE]

    Source CW #3941 IE (Delhi 19/10/19)

    Thanks.

    ReplyDelete
  128. @A Singh:
    1. Lists some rogues(5) HEELS
    This is a double definition.
    When something "lists" or "heels" (verb), it tilts.
    A "heel" (noun) is a comtemptible person. So, some rogues are heels.

    2. Very light, for example(5) FLARE
    A reference to Flare gun: "The most common type of flare gun is a Very (sometimes spelled Verey),[1] which was named after Edward Wilson Very (1847–1910), an American naval officer who developed and popularized a single-shot breech-loading snub-nosed pistol that fired flares (Very lights)."

    ReplyDelete
  129. Hi, is there any place or forum to discuss The Indian Express crossword clues? For example, this one from Crossword 4306 (Dec 19, 2020): Warm water to them is a vital necessity (8,4): TROPICAL FISH.
    Searching online, I found many places where they provide correct solution to this clue (without explanation). Is it so that recent Indian Express clues / crosswords are copied from old puzzles elsewhere, instead of original puzzle setting?

    ReplyDelete
  130. Hi Aniket, You're right - the Indian Express crossword is a re-run of an old UK-syndicated crossword. This clue looks like a straight-ish "cryptic definition" - can't spot any wordplay element in it.

    Over a decade ago, there used to be an active Orkut community which discussed the Indian Express crossword. Sadly Orkut's closure brought an end to it. I don't know of any other today - let me know if you do find one!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Shuchi! Will let you know if I find some discussion online.

      Delete
  131. I am sad to say that I created this clue, have forgotten the solution.
    To make it worse, I was new at creating cryptics at the time. This clue may not be properly formed, thereby offering no solution.
    Nonetheless, I call upon you for a possible answer.
    "Superman joins pals for charges" (7)
    Here's hoping!
    Thank you,
    Ken

    ReplyDelete
  132. @Ken: Intriguing situation! Do you have more to go upon, such as crossing letters? I am trying to make it work as a charade with definition 'charges', not getting anywhere with that. I invite others to take a stab at it!

    ReplyDelete
  133. I've been trying to crack "Superman joins pals for charges" (7) but have no leads.

    I do wonder if there's a place (perhaps this post is fine for it) where people can get feedback on their clue crafting.

    For example, are "easy" clues frowned upon. I know part of the joy of the cryptic is the challenge but is a simple one occasionally appreciated.

    E.g. "Went out with someone stuck in the past" (5)

    Thank you for your amazing blog!

    ReplyDelete
  134. Hi sarashinai,

    Thanks for your nice words about the blog!

    I can suggest crossword communities online for clue feedback.
    e.g.
    Facebook groups CCS and 1ACross.
    THCC hosts Sunday special crosswords set by hobbyist setters; if you'd like to get feedback on a full grid you might want to reach out to the owner Col Gopinath.

    ReplyDelete
  135. Hi Shuchi, this website is a great resource. Thank you so much for it.

    One I'm a bit perplexed about is from the independent for today.

    North American doctor that's preserving innocence.

    The answer is NAIVETE but i don't know how it's got.

    The only thing i can glean from this is the NA and that innocence is the definition.

    Thanks in advance!

    ReplyDelete
  136. Thanks for the compliment, Varun!

    North American doctor that's preserving innocence
    Definition: innocence
    Wordplay: NA (North American) + [ VET (doctor) in IE (that's) ]

    For the Independent crossword solutions, I recommend https://www.fifteensquared.net - this blog explains each clue and has interesting discussions in the comments section.

    ReplyDelete
  137. Hi. Sunday TOI. Cryptic clue. 'convict about to come up for a drink'. I've got the answer as 'lager'. Please help with the deconstruction.

    ReplyDelete
  138. Hi Rohit,

    convict about to come up for a drink = LAGER

    This is a charade + reversal in a Down clue.
    Definition: a drink
    Wordplay: LAG (convict) + RE (about) to come up i.e. reversed

    ReplyDelete
  139. Greater politician disrupted PM's Process 5,12

    ReplyDelete