Sponsored Links

A somewhat uncommon clueing style is to exchange a part of a word with something else to get the solution. Say, the word  CAST can be clued as CART - R + S.

Substitution Clue Structure: The clue has the following components:

1. Source Definition – Definition of the "input" word in which the substitution has to take place
2. Wordplay for letters to be removed
3. Wordplay for letters to be added
4. Substitution Indicator – e.g. 'instead of', 'in place of'
5. Solution Definition – Definition of the "output" word obtained after substitution

A good clue camouflages the substitution indicator well so that the solver misses spotting it – but once you’ve identified the clue as a substitution clue type, it gets much easier from there. Since the clue contains pointers for the source word, letters to be added/removed, you have a lot of fodder to build the solution upon.

Example I (from Times 24104):
Unexciting story gets mark for length (4)
story = source definition = TALE
mark for length => put in M in place of L
unexciting = solution definition = TA{-L}{+M}E = TAME

Example II (from Guardian 24522):
Too satisfied by praise when account is taken for one million (10)
praise = source definition = COMPLIMENT
account is taken for one million => put in AC in place of IM
too satisfied = solution definition = COMPL{-IM}{+AC}ENT = COMPLACENT

---
Solving Tips

• The portion to be substituted is usually 1-2 characters long only, which means that we need to think of two words – the source and the solution - that share almost similar spelling. This can be quite helpful as both words have their own definitions.

• The letters to be added/removed are mostly clued using standard abbreviations. With these letters identified, you have a good start point to find the source word/solution.

---
Try solving this one from the Guardian archives:
Poles in place of Royal Society in place of plants in place of sisters (7)
---

Related Posts:

• Other Clue Types: Anagrams, Hidden Words, Charades, Containers,
                             Reversals, Double Definitions, Homophones, Deletions, 
                             Acrostics, Cryptic Definitions, &Lit.

If you wish to keep track of further articles on Crossword Unclued, you can subscribe to it in a reader via RSS Feed. You can also subscribe by email and have articles delivered to your inbox.